Wednesday, June 9, 2021

UPDATED: There Must Be A Better Word

The word phobia generally connotes an irrational fear of something. A definition of the term from a mental health perspective tells us it is

a type of anxiety disorder that is characterized by extreme and debilitating fear of an object, place, situation, or creature (usually insects) which is usually not dangerous. A person does not need to have direct contact with the thing they’re afraid of to experience symptoms. Even thinking about it can bring on anxiety or panic symptoms. 

Phobias run the gamut from agoraphobia (fear of open spaces or crowds) to xenophobia (fear of strangers or foreigners) to zoophobia (fear of animals). All of these definitions have one thing in common: fear or social anxiety, a form of mental illness.

And that is why the term islamophobia, even though it goes beyond fear of Muslims or Islam to include hatred of, and prejudice against, them, seems wholly inadequate, especially in light of the recent horrifying events that unfolded in London, Ontario. It is almost as if the word is a euphemism for something much darker.

It is time to confront the fact that Canadians are not exempt from the racism that has long afflicted the United States, racism reflected in the residential school system our country embraced for so long, racism that is sadly evident in the ongoing crimes against minorities, not the least of whom are Muslims.

In her searing column today, Susan Delacourt calls out federal leaders for refusing denounce the anti-Islamic nature of Quebec's Bill-21, which prohibits the wearing of religious garb for anyone who seeks to hold a public service job. This, while these same federal leaders offer expressions of sympathy and solidarity with the Muslim community. What credibility, for example, does Erin O'Toole have when his party during the 2015 election campaign promised the infamous snitch line for "barbaric cultural practices," a dog-whistle if there ever was one?

But the most damning indictment of Canadian racism comes in this story:

Jeff Bennett, who ran for the PCs in the 2014 election, recounted in a Facebook post how people in his riding were happy to see that he had replaced the former candidate, a man named Ali Chahbar. Loyal Conservatives in London told Bennett they were relieved that “his name was English and his skin was white.” Bennett remembered how Chahbar had been smeared on local talk radio with talk of sharia law and other nonsense.

Bennett wrote that he was tired of people saying London was better than what happened on Sunday. “Bullshit. I knocked on thousands of doors in the very neighbourhood this atrocity occurred. This terrorist may have been alone in that truck on that day, but he was not acting alone. He was raised in a racist city that pretends it isn’t.”

Bennett came in second in London West in 2014 and has likely abandoned any aspirations to be elected again, given his willingness to tell voters what they don’t want to hear about themselves.

Being willing and able to confront unpalatable truths about ourselves will not rid us of those truths, But, in the long road toward a better society, it has to be the first step.

UPDATE: The following, by David Doel of The Rational National, offers a wider landscape upon which to view Canada's racism:




6 comments:

  1. Happy to say I never drank from the tainted cup of fear and misguided stupidity. In fact, knowing that the arse that was Bush jr had place Lebanon on his 7 country hit-list (other than saying everything that is FUBAR globally now because of corporate takeover)------we opened our home to (only) Lebanese (thru a church in our city). Now into our second Lebanese renter (s) we feel content and useful. A feeling that many not only need but are desperate for while being asinine enough to listen/watch the propaganda spewed by our own ultra-biased media. I have discontinued all papers --online/cable viewing till some sense and decency returns.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good for your church, Marg. As well, it is a pity others do not boycott the ultra- biased media outlets that only promote hate and division. The Kool-Aid they have on offer is being drunk by far too many.

      Delete
  2. We know, Lorne, that no one is born a racist. It's a learned behaviour. Bigotry is inculcated. There are those who stoke fear in others. Tribalism is founded on bigotry, fear/hostility toward "the other." We see this openly parading on the streets of the Lord of the Flies Republic next door.

    I know a Muslim doctor who emigrated to Canada from Ireland four years ago. He found more Islamophobia here than anything he experienced in Ireland. He related what a fellow Muslim, a guy who has been here for decades told him. This fellow said that, when he arrived, ordinary Canadians were quite gracious and welcoming. Many were interested in learning about his homeland and culture.

    As the older generation retired and was replaced by a younger generation something changed. Bigotry surfaced that he had never experienced before.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Watching the local news tonight, Mound, many Muslim women were talking about how they encounter racist harassment almost every day. It saddens me to see such ubiquitous hatred of the other, all the more reason it is vial to confront it head-on. We all have a role to play in combatting it.

      Delete
  3. It's a longer conversation than anyone in this country is willing to have and it should have started at least forty-nine years ago, or even before that. The absence of thoroughness in the discourse that has taken place since then has precluded the possibility that rationality will prevail.

    Meanwhile, as our academics and political leaders compete for the titles of Emoter-in-Chief and Presiding Apologist, I'll maintain my loose association with the "Well,-All I-Know-Is" fraternity. The indirect victims of another's atychiphobia are far fewer than the direct and indirect ones of his moral certainty, irrespective of the flag that's being waved.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Emoter-in-Chief and Presiding Apologist have a real resonance John. Very apt. As for atychiphobia (fear of failure0, well, I'll admit I had to look that one up.

      Delete