If the true measure of a society is to be found in how it treats its most vulnerable members, Ontario, under the Doug Ford regime, and all those who voted for it, must be found wanting.
Perhaps it is a function of age, but the older I get as I continue to enjoy a comfortable retirement, the more my thoughts turn to the less fortunate in our society, a segment that was enjoying demonstrable improvement in the quality of their lives thanks to the basic income project imitated under the former Wynne government. Unfortunately, despite his campaign promise to continue with the experiment for its intended three-year term, Doug Ford broke his word and cancelled it early, the final cheque being sent out this month.
And the consequences will be severe:
Under the pilot project, individuals received up to about $17,000 annually while couples could get up to about $24,000. A top-up of $6,000 was available for those with disabilities.Consider a few of the people whose lives were starting to show measurable improvement under the program, as reported last year:
In addition to fewer rules and surveillance, basic income was more generous than social assistance, which provides an annual income for basic needs and shelter of almost $9,000 for individuals, $13,600 for couples and just over $14,000 for a person with a disability.
Wendy Moore, who has been homeless for almost two years, is looking for an apartment.Or consider Lindsay resident Kathy Mahood, 53:
After couch-surfing for almost two years, Moore, 60, is using her basic income payment to look for stable housing.
“My biggest focus is getting my own place and giving poor John his apartment back,” said Moore, who has been sleeping on her friend’s living room sofa for about a year.
Before joining the program in October, the single mother of six and grandmother of 12 was “barely surviving” on $330 a month in basic needs allowance from Ontario Works, the province’s welfare program for people without disabilities. [Because she was homeless, she did not qualify for a shelter allowance]
But under the basic income experiment, Moore receives $1,416 a month, an amount that remains constant no matter where she lives.
“It is giving me back my independence,” she said. “I don’t feel so backed into a corner. If I want to eat, I can afford to buy something instead of going to a food bank or a soup kitchen.”
When she joined the pilot project in October [2017], she was living on about $735 a month in federal Canada Pension Plan disability benefits and proceeds from the sale of her house.But those dreams are all over for many, many people. Here is how a few beneficiaries of the project plan to spend their last cheque this month:
“I figured I had a year and a half left before I would lose my apartment and have to rent a room. It was pretty frightening,” she said.
But with $1,200 in basic income every month on top of her disability benefits, Mahood has money for rent and healthy food — and has begun making regular payments to clear her credit card debt.
“If I am careful, I should be debt-free when the program ends in three years,” she said.
Mahood was able to buy modest Christmas gifts for her four grandchildren in December. She could afford to buy ingredients for Christmas baking. She can put gas in her car and has money for repairs.
“I feel healthier and I am not stressed all the time about money,” she said.
Carmen Lord, 46, of Hamilton, who works part time in a dry-cleaning shop.Broken political promises are nothing new, of course, but to break a commitment on the backs of the most vulnerable surely tells us everything we need to know about the Doug Ford government and those who voted for, and continue to support, it.
Monthly basic income: $1,415
Last payment will be spent on making extra car and auto insurance payments so she doesn’t lose her car.
“When I got the basic income in April (2018) I used the extra money to buy a car so it would be easier to get to work,” said Lord, who had a full-time job at a tech-support company at the time. “When I was laid off last fall, the basic income helped me stay ahead of my bills. But now I’m panicking. If I can’t find a full-time job, I will lose my car.”
Tracey Crosson, 47, of Thunder Bay, who moved to Toronto in January for better medical care.
Monthly basic income: $1,916
Last payment will be spent on credit card debt and advance payments for hydro, phone and internet.
“I need to get ahead of my bills because I am going to be living on $168 after rent (in May),” said Crosson, who has relied on ODSP on and off for the past 20 years due to an accident and will return to the program in April. Her monthly income will drop to just $1,169.
“It’s going to be tight. I need to pay ahead on my bills and get some extra food so I’m not starving. If I don’t do this, I’m either going to be dead or starving in six months.”
Dana Bowman, a 57-year-old grandmother from Lindsay.
Monthly basic income: $1,916
Last payment will be spent on grocery cards, advance payments for phone and internet, and household basics like toilet paper.
“The basic income gave me more courage to talk about poverty. It gave us a chance to give our input on what works for us instead of (the government) sticking us in boxes that haven’t worked in the past,” she said. “It’s going to be hard to go back to living on just $667 a month for basic needs … and not being able to afford healthy snacks when my grandchildren come to visit.”
All in all, not a pretty snapshot of our species.
