Tuesday, March 22, 2011

A Harper-Orchestrated Attempt To “Change The Channel”

Watching last night's edition of CBC's Power and Politics, as I frequently do, offered yet another opportunity for insight into the Harper mind, a mind that many would describe as dark, manipulative, and contemptuous of everyone outside of 'the Conservative philosophical tent' (which, when you think about it, must be a small abode indeed, given its very restricted range of thought and vision.)

The predictable discussion occurred throughout the first half-hour of the show, as Liberal Scott Brison, Conservative Tom Lukiwski and the NDP's Yvon Godin discussed the contempt of Parliament verdict by the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs. As was to be expected, Tory Lukiwski spun the partisan and already frequently-repeated line that the contempt finding was simply partisan politics and a sham. This is, of course, the Conservative narrative, one we will hear incessantly if an election is called. However, the really interesting development came in the next half hour.

In that segment, Solomon was interviewing Conservative James Rajotte, Liberal Ralph Goodale, and the NDP's Thomas Mulcair about the pending federal budget and how the contempt finding might affect the vote on it. Suddenly, looking at his Blackberry, Evan Solomon broke in with the news that there had been a leak about the Conservative budget, and he then went on to articulate the details of the leak: forgiveness of student loans for medical personnel willing to work in isolated areas, money for research and development, etc. At that point I believe Mr. Solomon thought that the CBC had scored a coup. I told my wife that there are no leaks in the Tory 'ship of state' (please forgive the tired metaphor), and that this revelation was clearly designed for another purpose.

My 'spider sense' tingling, I switched over to CTV's Power Play with Don Martin where, lo and behold, he was announcing the same leaks, when previously he had been talking about the contempt finding. Back on CBC, Solomon was trying to get Mulcair and Goodale to evaluate the specific details leaked and wisely they demurred, suggesting to the host that he was simply being used by the Tory apparatus for spin purposes. Solomon did look decidedly disappointed a few minutes later when he announced on-air that the leaks had been sent to several news agencies.

This transparent attempt to 'change the channel' away from discussion of the contempt of Parliament finding, I think, gives us an idea of how the Harper regime will conduct their campaign, should an election be called. Today may well see the beginning of the process culminating in a non-confidence motion on the budget so that the Government will fall on that issue, thereby circumventing a formal vote in Parliament on the contempt findings, which would allow the Conservatives to continue during the campaign with the narrative that the Committee’s finding of contempt is, once more, only a partisan sham, proven by the fact that the opposition voted down a responsible budget that would have benefited all Canadians.

It is clear to me that yesterday's above-described events offer potent proof that the Harper Government's contempt is hardly limited to Parliament. It suggests a mentality that cynically views most people as easily manipulated, easily distracted, and easily convinced to overlook all of the egregious violations of democracy they are guilty of.

God help us if they are right.

6 comments:

  1. The leakage of some key points of the budget is a serious issue. There are reasons why budgets are kept very secret (e.g. they can affect the financial markets). This is why media are locked down before the budget is announced. In this case, it seems to be even more serious as the leaks appear to be designed for some political advantage for the Harper govt.

    Why are the opposition not pointing out that intentional leaking of key budget issues is contempt of Parliament because it obstructs the functioning of Parliament by playing political games (in this case, probably intended to put public pressure on the NDP)?

    The political media has been disappointing -- not a single peep about the propiety of these budget leaks. But then this is the same media that seemed not to have been aware that Harper had hired as adviser someone who has a criminal record.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You raise some excellent points here. I too have noticed not a single word about the seriousness of those leaks in today's papers, probably yet another indication of the poor job the media are doing in holding the Harper regime to account.

    I do intend to watch the special "At Issue" panel being convened tonight on The National to see if this issue is raised.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The leaks would be serious enough even if they were unintended, or surreptitiously provided to some journalist/media. However, in this case, it seems to be intentionally coming from the government itself, if I am reading all these news reports correctly.

    Hopefully, the opposition and/or some watchdog would take this matter up.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That's an amazing catch, Lorne. Good stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Evan Solomon: useful idiot. Not a surprise, really. Watching his performance with the leaders of the opposition yesterday pretty much remove his partisan mask. He was actually negotiating with Layton, trying to get him to commit to specific amendments that would buy support.

    ReplyDelete