Thursday, April 9, 2020

On Covid-19 Fake News



I received a lovely note the other day from a reader named Rose. While I am pleased she finds my blog a useful resource, I am also happy that she included a very pertinent link as an aide in spotting fake news, especially that involving our current pandemic. I shall return to that link in a moment.

But first, how big a problem is disinformation during this time of fear and uncertainty?

The Guardian cites the growing problem of prominent people who apparently have more fame than brains:
The actor Woody Harrelson and the singer MIA have faced criticism after sharing baseless claims about the supposed connection of 5G to the pandemic, while comments by the likes of the Brazilian president, Jair Bolsonaro, playing down the scale of the crisis in the face of scientific evidence have attracted criticism in recent days.
Such ravings have consequences.
The issue has gained extra prominence as Britons began vandalising mobile phone masts in recent days amid wildly sharing baseless claims linking the virus to 5G.

There is growing concern that online disinformation could be having real world health impacts. Research by Dr Daniel Allington, senior lecturer in social and cultural artificial intelligence at King’s College London, suggested there was a statistically notable link between people who believed false claims about the coronavirus and people who were willing to flout the government’s social distancing guidelines.

His findings, based on a experimental study conducted in coordination with the Centre for Countering Digital Hate, found that people who said they believed coronavirus was connected to 5G mobile phone masts are less likely to be staying indoors, washing their hands regularly or respecting physical distancing.
Even more unhinged is Roseanne Barr who, in a phone interview with Norm Macdonald, had this to say about the bug:
"You know what it is, Norm? I think they're just trying to get rid of all my generation...."The boomer ladies that, you know, that inherited their — you know, are widows. They inherited the money so they got to go wherever the money is and figure out a way to get it away from people."

Barr made a number of other unorthodox claims during the interview: She argued that people are "being forced to evolve," urged working women to learn how to make bean soup, claimed that Chinese people eat bats and rats (and that she saw one guy eat a baby), and insisted that "there exists an operative in each town that reports back to Central Intelligence false information to ruin my career."
If you want to read more about this supremely unbalanced lady, Venay Menon has a droll take on her escapades.

Misinformation can be deadly, especially as it pertains to Covid-19. Perennial huckster/televangelist Jim Bakker is facing legal consequences after peddling a snake oil called Liquid Silver Sol he claimed would protect people from the bug. One hopes that the convicted felon pays a heavy price for his dangerous advocacy.

Which brings us back to the question of how to best inoculate ourselves against the virus of hysterical untruths. Readers of this blog will know that I have long been an advocate of critical thinking as the best protective; as I have said many times, it is an ideal toward which I continually strive, well-aware that I often fall short.

Reading widely of legitimate sources is a vital nutrient in this quest, but happily there are some readily accessible sites that make it easier. Snopes, of course, is one of the best. Its recent effort to dispel the myth that eating alkaline foods will confer protection against Covid-19 is an apt illustration of its usefulness.

A search engine can be of great benefit as well. Try putting the term fake news covid-19 into one and look at the results.

There are many, many useful resources on the web which I am confident you can access with little difficulty, and so I leave you with the site suggested by my correspondent Rose. Called Website Planet, it offers some very useful guidance and tools in our collective quest for truth and accuracy.

The Covid-19 virus is naturally dominating all of our concerns today. However, working to flatten the curve on the pandemic of misinformation that existed before and will continue long after the bug is managed will surely serve us well in the bigger picture known as everyday life, life that we will, eventually, return to.

10 comments:

  1. Kevin Phillips in his 2005 book, American Theocracy, discusses an abrupt rise in magical thinking in empires/dominant economies as they enter decline.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think I have read that, Mound. Thanks for the tip. Magical thinking is clearly the modus operandi of far too many people today, and the role it is playing in the rapidly unwinding American Empire is manifestly evident.

      Delete
  2. Magical thinking -- like the cockroach -- seems to survive all assaults, Lorne. The way to prevent cockroach invasions is to be continually vigilent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vigilance is truly one of the only effective measures against the lazy and deranged thinkers amongst us, Owen.

      Delete
  3. .. A brilliant & truly timely post.. It goes well with several others served up via Progressive Bloggers.. A quick bit o housekeeping.. Some wonder at my obvious interest & extreme concern re Alberta. Most of my family resides there.. as did I, some years back.. 'We have history'.. I hope that suffices.. and last I looked Alberta was still an integral part of Canada, loved, treasured, mystical, powerful.. astonishing..

    So.. down to business.. Magical Thinking.. deary me.. ! Here comes a whopper.. after, I will reveal the no magic reality.

    As Jason Kenney strives to save Alberta from deep pocket foreign funded 'environmentalists' there are others, lefty instigators & trolls, even lefty liberal MPs who also want to shut down Canada's critical Oil & Gas Industry. They will stop at nothing & use Media that's in their pocket to constantly attack getting our resources to new markets as well as stop us ensuring Energy Security is enjoyed by all Canadians. Why Alberta cuts equalization cheques to Quebec and Ontario and receives nothing in return is senseless and wrong.. and yet Alberta has been driving and growing the Canadian Economy for years, despite the constant fake news from Media. We have over 73 Billion barrels of Oil in Alberta and only lack of pipelines to hungry markets is holding us back..

    Magical Thinking .. echoed top down from Jason Kenney, Sonya Savage.. via Post Media and other careless MainMedia.. 'Conservatives' in general.

    OK .. let's deep dive non Magical..

    Reality is not that 96% of 'Canada's Vast Oil Reserves' are actually 'oil'.. Reality is that 'conventional oil' pumped from a well, comprises 4% .. Yes, 96% is actually Bitumen.. and that buried petroleum resource must be upgraded somewhat, blended with refined condensate / diluent.. to form a slurry called dilbit.. some of which is called WCS - Western Canada Select dilbit. Neither Alberta or Canada will be an 'Energy Superpower'.. Only if the poles were reversed.. and the Tar Sands.. were actually 'oil sands' .. and such that 96% of Canada's Vast Oil Reserves' were actually.. uh.. 'oil'.. and a measly 4% was Bitumen.

    Mr Kenney et al, in the manner of Stephen Harper.. keeps spouting & perpetrating a myth... 'Magical Thinking'.. and lo, the people believe. Of course we all want a magic potion, an elixer, a cure-all.. a quick fix, a kool-aid wonder drink.. We seem to prefer comic book political heroes over tireless nurses or educators.. we savor sensational.. & contraversy.. we seem to love partisan drama over calm efficiency or proficiency.. love instant hype over coherence.. an invisible friend who resides upstairs in a cloud will save us.. and slay the brown infadel.. Thoughts n Prayers eh .. sheesh ..




    So

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The mythology that feeds Albertan disenchantment is extensive, Sal; those who buy into it badly need some schooling on the facts. In today's Star, Gillian Stewardhas a good piece on the Wexit movement:

      https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/2020/04/07/suddenly-an-independent-alberta-doesnt-seem-so-appealing.html

      Delete
  4. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/09/how-america-lost-its-mind/534231/

    ReplyDelete
  5. .. the Atlantic link leads to an astonishing read. Have seen several like it.. while looking at evangelicals in politics.. Its a toss up who is the most dangerous.. the bizarre ones like William Barr.. or the bizarre ones like Donald Trump who fake it.. and does it really matter, anyway ? All the posturing & preening in their Sunday 'Best' - Thoughts & Prayers wafting from the White House.. to their chattering disciples.. Its just daily Theatre of the Grotesque.. the Church of Unadulterated Greed & Certitude

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed, Sal, their posturing stinks to high heaven.

      Delete