Saturday, February 24, 2024

The Language Of Genocide

 


“Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind. ”

― George Orwell

It is very easy, in the majority of cases, to become quickly inured to the world's suffering. Whether it be earthquakes and crime in Haiti, famine in Africa, or the war Russia is waging against Ukraine, we reach the point of compassion fatigue, facilitated no doubt by the lack of any apparent resolution to the dire circumstances so many experience in today's fractured world. 

One hopes against hope that the genocide taking place in Gaza may prove an exception, however, despite the efforts of so many to make the Israeli response to the October 7 attack by Hamas look both reasonable and necessary. And one of the latest to make such an effort is our own (were it not so) Stephen Harper.

Shree Paradkar writes:

On Wednesday, former Canadian prime minister Stephen Harper was in Jerusalem, shaking hands with the butcher of Gaza, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. According to his tweet, Harper witnessed "an Israel scarred by the unprovoked horrors of Oct. 7, but also united in its determination to end the threat of Hamas once and for all."

"Unprovoked." "Ending the threat of Hamas." Phrases being repeatedly used to justify the unjustifiable.

It is no doubt a human tendency to try to interpret the world along absolutist terms; things are either good or bad, thereby circumventing the hard work that critical thinking requires. For his fellow travellers, Stephen Harper is providing such a service.

But historical context is needed.

The Hamas commander named the attack "Al Aqsa Floods" saying it was meant to avenge Israel's brutal attacks on Al Aqsa mosque in East Jerusalem — long a flashpoint site — during Ramadan in 2021.

Whatever one makes of that statement, it's a reminder that one can't look at what's happening without context. Insisting on erasing the context of current events — as seen with the repetition of the word "unprovoked" — is very much in Israel's interest. It allows Israel to position itself as the innocent party and to reduce the unspeakable violence it has unleashed to a "they-asked-for-it" rhetoric.

But there is much more involved here, years of abuse and repression that the world refuses to acknowledge.

There is so much mutual pain in the region that to ignore the underlying conditions of violence is to create conditions that lead to violence.

Some of these conditions include decades of repressive and vicious Israeli military occupation in Palestinian territories, with Israel routinely displacing, imprisoning and killing Palestinians. Israel's illegal blockade segregated Gazans from the world for years by banning them from travelling outside. The majority of Gazans are refugees who face sweeping restrictions on the entry and exit of goods. Israel even controlled the flow of electricity and water; more than 90 per cent of the water in Gaza was unfit for consumption before Oct. 7. A Washington Post report found there had been no natural surface water in Gaza since the early 2000s.

For even greater context, there is an array of videos available on YouTube attesting to the mistreatment of Arabs in the entire region.

Paradkar also talks about how the Palestinian cause has been conflated with Hamas and Islamic extremism, making it easier to dehumanize them, meaning
no matter how Israel treats Palestinians, whether it attacks Gaza's hospitals, kills and maims children, doctors, academics and journalists, or whether the International Court of Justice has ruled that Israel must take action to prevent genocidal violence by its armed forces, in Israel's view and in the eyes of its Western allies, it remains the wronged party.

It is this mentality that Harper has shamefully tapped into, making it easier to minimize and justify Israel's ongoing atrocities. 

Decades ago, George Orwell warned us about the destructive effects of political language. Sadly, it seems we have learned little to nothing in the intervening years.



20 comments:

  1. It is said that those abused become abusers themselves.
    History repeats itself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sadly, that certainly seems to be the case here, TB.

      Delete
  2. In Victor Frankls' book The Search For Meaning ( observations of a psychologist camp survivor) he noted that the abused can go both ways. Either into brutal unfeeling abusive behavior or into infinitely empathetic compassion for every living thing.
    The israeli/harperesk "measured response and self defence has come to mean unmeasured infinite ratio infliction of punishing suffering and pre-emptive offensive elimination of any perceived threat of even verbal opposition far into the future. Both are entitled deluded entities with a very narrow view of who is welcome in their gods universe. Those that support either are willing to promote the very worst of humanity and like Canadians on many other issues happy to promote a vision they are excluded from . (Those tax cuts will always be for them and never for you ....axe the tax ....what a load of crap 'lil pp)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There are many among us who resist changes to the status quo, lungta. They seem to lack the vision and humanity necessary for a better world.

      Delete
  3. An interesting presentation by Wang Yi, PRC Foreign Minister at the International Court of Justice.

    https://twitter.com/i/status/1760597515089416265

    It seems to suggest Canada's policy towards the Israel-Palestinian conflict is misguided. Or as a human rights lawyer mentioned, complicit in genocide.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the link, Anon. While it is a bit rich for the Chinese to try to occupy the high moral ground here, the delegate's words resonate.

      Delete
    2. While it is a bit rich for the Chinese to try to occupy the high moral ground

      Well, while China's idea of human rights is not exactly ours they do not condone genocide.

      Delete
    3. True, but they can be pretty hard on those who disagree with the government.

      Delete
  4. It is this mentality that Harper has shamefully tapped into,
    True I saw through Harper's religious leanings from day one!
    Hence my dislike of any politician of any party that places belief in the occult and superstition.
    Yes that includes Singh.
    Believing in these silly superstitions is the root of many world wide problematic issues.
    That includes those that merely profess to believe in such whilst acting in a very different direction.
    TB

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is a great deal of hypocrisy in today's politicians, TB. Profession of religious beliefs is often an excuse for abysmal behaviour.

      Delete
  5. Am quite familiar re a full range of ‘WARS’ - Anyone reasonably coherent - age 70 who’s read diversely has by sheer osmosis - absorbed a basis of such knowledge - in particular I’ve always been drawn to ‘adventurism’ - exploration - stories of exemplars - even natural catastrophes - as well as a vast cross section of other human activity.. Yes have read & learned a ton re War

    In short - already knowing approx Mortality of the ‘War’ in Gaza has been ‘stalled’ in Mainstream Media at approx 29,000 for a month..
    - today saw an update in Ukraine of 10,000 Dead after two years

    These are two different Invasions in my view - one being an approximation of what I would expect if Russia attacked Ukraine ie ‘a ground & arial war over extended terrain - mechanized ground troops, aircraft & missiles. As well Russia is attacking from the sea in specific areas

    The other essentially an invasion better described as ‘Urban Warfare’ conducted within Gaza that includes attack from the sea as well.

    The respective ‘Ratios’ of Combatants - Invaders vs Defenders
    is approx 10 - 1 in Ukraine
    Have no real idea the Ratio of Israeli military versus Hamas guerrilla terrorists

    Realistically Russia & Ukraine have similar armaments
    Comparing Israel armaments to Hamas is essentially ridiculous

    In summary - I did not expect Ukraine to survive this long at all..
    & assumed the ‘War’ in Gaza would last a week or two & was correct - This is no longer a ‘War’ - what is underway is a ‘Great Levelling’ - the obliteration of Gaza Infrastructure via Air Strikes & Artillery - the surviving Citizenry being Driven - Expelled elsewhere. What is underway is Securing of a Temporary Police State while bulldozers & earth moving equipment begin reorganizing the residue, levelling & recategorization of the urban landscape into sectors for re-purposing. Since Israel had already seized control of the sea and marine resources - Gaza is now Israel Sovereign Land

    A final word - We have not seen Tactical Nuclear Weapons utilized in either Conflict .. YET ! Locally Radiating ground military or localized strategic territory via ‘man portable’ nuclear armament or strategic surgical arial strikes renders the land, soil, waters & infrastructure radioactive for possibly thousands of years. These are Wars for Territory & Resources

    We already know that Houthis are attacking shipping with missiles - not small gunboats. When & whether Religious Zealots will aquire such weapons is one burning question - whether they will attack Israel with them may not even be a useful question at all
    🦎🏴‍☠️

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your analysis, Sal. The prolonged war in Ukraine is definitely much different than the 'war against Hamas', Hamas serving as a pretext for the ongoing genocide in Gaza. The levelling of the infrastructure in Gaza, has essentially rendered it uninhabitable, and my guess is that it will not be rebuilt until all the Gazans have either been killed or dispersed to other countries.

      Delete
    2. An excellent article in The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists examines the staggering Carbon Footprint of the Two invasions, the respective Adversaries as well as the Re-Supply
      Another excellent Factual Source is bellingcat of course - matchless Open Source Investigative Analysis & Reportage
      🦎🏴‍☠️

      Delete
    3. Thanks for the information. I'll check it out, Sal.

      Delete
  6. Does this image put a shiver up your back?

    https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/f494d758931c2d281d363c3be036ebc61a13ad68/0_240_3607_2164/master/3607.jpg?width=1900&quality=85&auto=format&fit=max&s=887f645a84753962eead1c0036905e5a

    TB

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very interesting, TB. Is this the IDF in Gaza?

      Delete
  7. Yes it is.
    I suppose those girls will post their 'conquest' on face book to see how many likes they get!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are shocking in their jaded cynicism, TB.

      Delete
  8. A view by a man that spends time in the ME.

    https://ericmargolis.com/2023/12/stop-the-slaughter-in-palestine/

    TB

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the link, TB. A very sobering read, one that offers little hope for improvement given the long history of oppression of the Palestinians by Israel.

      Delete