Wednesday, January 21, 2015

The Real Problem With Contemporary Journalism



The current scandal engulfing the CBC and Amanda Lang has made its way overseas into the cross-hairs of The Guardian's George Monbiot.

After providing a summary, with appropriate links, of the sordid Lang tale that encompasses massive conflict of interest and management collusion, Monbiot has this to say:
CBC refused to answer my questions, and I have not had a response from Lang. It amazes me that she remains employed by CBC, which has so far done nothing but bluster and berate its critics.
But the CBC's indefensible stance is not the real subject of Monbiot's essay, merely part of the context for his thesis:
[T]hose who are supposed to scrutinise the financial and political elite are embedded within it. Many belong to a service-sector aristocracy, wedded metaphorically (sometimes literally) to finance. Often unwittingly, they amplify the voices of the elite, while muffling those raised against it.
Studies and statistic prove his point:
A study by academics at the Cardiff School of Journalism examined the BBC Today programme’s reporting of the bank bailouts in 2008. It discovered that the contributors it chose were “almost completely dominated by stockbrokers, investment bankers, hedge fund managers and other City voices. Civil society voices or commentators who questioned the benefits of having such a large finance sector were almost completely absent from coverage.” The financiers who had caused the crisis were asked to interpret it.
The heavily biased reporting on that catastrophe, however, was only representative of a deeper malaise:
The same goes for discussions about the deficit and the perceived need for austerity. The debate has been dominated by political and economic elites, while alternative voices – arguing that the crisis has been exaggerated, or that instead of cuts, the government should respond with Keynesian spending programmes or taxes on financial transactions, wealth or land – have scarcely been heard. Those priorities have changed your life: the BBC helped to shape the political consensus under which so many are now suffering.
And what about fair and balanced reporting? A fiction, according to Monbiot:
The BBC’s business reporting breaks its editorial guidelines every day by failing to provide alternative viewpoints. Every weekday morning, the Today programme grovels to business leaders for 10 minutes. It might occasionally challenge them on the value or viability of their companies, but hardly ever on their ethics. Corporate critics are shut out of its business coverage – and almost all the rest.

On BBC News at Six, the Cardiff researchers found, business representatives outnumbered trade union representatives by 19 to one. “The BBC tends to reproduce a Conservative, Eurosceptic, pro-business version of the world,” the study said. This, remember, is where people turn when they don’t trust the corporate press.
He ends by listing the media's myriad failures, and the grave consequence of those failures:
...their failure to expose the claims of the haut monde, their failure to enlist a diversity of opinion, their failure to permit the audience to see that another world is possible. If even the public sector broadcasters parrot the talking points of the elite, what hope is there for informed democratic choice?

Monbiot's piece should be required reading for all concerned about the condition of that great protector of democracy, the fifth estate. As well, we would be indeed foolish if we failed to understand that the insights he offers apply, not just to Great Britain, but to Canada and much of the rest of western world, as well.

8 comments:

  1. Another article I'll share with my classes! Monbiot's practically writing my course these days.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wish I had had him to draw upon during my classroom days, Marie!

      Delete
  2. A good article Lorne. Welcome to neo-liberalism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm sure the 'true believers' are exultant, Pamela.

      Delete
  3. Thanks for this post, Lorne. I went directly to the Monbiot piece and I think he expressed this disgusting problem better than anyone else. Most cogent, for me, was his point that the public broadcaster is where we expect to turn when we can't trust the private, corporate media.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. it is very sad to see how we are being betrayed by national broadcasters these days, Mound, the CBC most especially.

      Delete
  4. Well, Lorne, I don't know if it was Monbiot or maybe you and Monbiot, but CBC management has scurried out from under their rock and will now prohibit on-air personnel from pocketing cash for personal appearances. Naturally they're working overtime to duck questions about their ethical change of heart.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the news, Mound. It is always heartening when management has a 'come to Jesus moment', no matter how impure the path leading there might have been.

      Delete