Saturday, January 11, 2020

Tell It Like It Is



I have written nothing about the Iranian missile that brought down the Ukrainian flight, frankly because I don't know what to say beyond the fact that it is an immense tragedy, not only due to the loss of life but because of who was killed: primarily young people with their entire lives ahead of them, and young people who were immensely talented, many PhD students, researchers and doctors. We will never know what they could have achieved, both for themselves and for the world.

What is clear, however, is the fact that Donald Trump has much blood on his hands. Had he not assassinated an Iranian citizen on sovereign soil, the Iranians would not have been on high alert and mistaken the doomed flight for an incoming missile. That the Psychopath-in-Chief feels no responsibility or remorse is a given here.

Canada's response to Trump's responsibility, of course, has been non-existent, so if we want some honest dialogue about this terrible event, we could do far worse than scanning the letter-writers' page in The Star:
For now, U.S. President Donald Trump’s vanity project — taking out Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani — has cost the lives of scores of Iranian mourners killed in a stampede at the general’s funeral, and scores of foreign nationals killed in a plane crash while desperately fleeing Tehran.

The only thing this self-serving president cares less about than Iranian lives is the lives of Iranian Canadians.

There is no room in Trump’s personal world view for effective diplomacy. Having turned Soleimani to smouldering ashes, he was too immature to remain quiet about it, but crowed and gloated, even as millions of grief-stricken mourners flooded the streets of Iran.

Trump may well be re-elected, such is the powerful pseudo-intimacy between him and his adoring followers.

Having said that, I understand Trump’s skepticism about handing back billions to the current Iranian regime, which clearly had a long shopping list of terror-related activities.

It is time now to reinstate a better version of the Iran nuclear pullback, or for Canada to quit the region entirely.

Ron Charach, Toronto


Three things are important to note on this crisis in the Middle East with Iran and the US.

One, U.S. President Donald Trump does not take ownership (or blame) for bringing the crisis to a head, but instead blames the Iranians and the late Gen. Qassem Soleimani.

Two, Trump has had his face slapped by the retaliatory missile strikes by Iran. He will not like this and inside it makes him feel humiliated and insecure. (My guess is that this personal response by him has been kept hidden.) He will be left surly, vindictive and unforgiving toward the Iranians.

Three, Trump will not abandon his goal of containing Iran and trying to prevent them from having nuclear weapons. Whether this is realistically attainable or not is another question.

Chaos, confusion, uncertainty, lack of clarity, worry and emotion, and nothing solved — once again the results of Trump’s actions. Both sides now know the other can strike with missiles.

Through all of this we must wonder, how come the U.S. defensive equipment did not knock down the Iranian missiles? Was the range too short for response, was the equipment even in place? Was all this puffery?

Norm Ferguson, Richmond Hill
It is often said that talk is cheap. I beg to differ. Had talk substituted for Trump's pathetic, impulsive and deranged behaviour, many, many people would still be alive today.

4 comments:

  1. Canada's response has been calm and measured . Commiserate and co-operate with Iranians and ignor Trump.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Trump does outrage Lorne . Canada as it should does diplomacy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. .. in previous comments here and elsewhere I omitted in error the reality that the Iranian chain of command could easily confirm whether any of its anti aircraft batteries had actually fired missiles and exactly when. I too was operating in the belief that of course there could be a coverup or resolute absolute denial.. or simply a closing of ranks around confidential airport or 'National Security'. Correspondingly, the radar and fire control data from any modern defense battery would be retained. It is the likely scenario for what we now know happened.

    Sadly we also know that at the very least, the family of Donald Trump knew in advance, as seemingly so did Trump's golf foursome that the US military would eliminate General Soleimani via drone strike. His illustrious son boasted openly via Twitter that 'a whole lot of whoopass' would be announced shortly.. before deleting the tweet later. Of course someone was alert enough on Twitter do do a screen grab of the tweet. Lest we be too critical of Iranian human error.. the full story of the US ship Vincennes shooting down an Iranian passenger aircraft in 1988 is an astonishing tale of human error and flawed military hardware.. the crew of that ship only realized their monumental error via various media sources.. they thought they 'had splashed' a military threat.

    The nationality of those killed has been revised to 57 passengers who boarded with Canadian passports.. but approx 130 or more that were aboard had a final destination in Canada. Presumably someone may winnow together all the facts re Donald Trump's call on the 'window' to kill General Soleimani and anyone in near proximity. He was flying via commercial aircraft after all & landed in Iraq.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember well the Vincennes debacle, Sal. Most memorable was that George Bush Sr.'s initial reaction was to proclaim that "the United States never apologizes," Years later, I believe they did just that.

      American exceptionalism is one of the biggest blights on the contemporary world, in my view.

      Delete