If one follows politics closely, it is easy to become quite jaded. On almost daily display are scenes of arrogance, condescension and the corrupting influence of power. We are reminded of those sorry aspects of our species regularly by Ontario's Doug Ford government, one I hesitate to label by any other name, as it seems increasingly to be a one-man show.
However, once in awhile we are reminded that there are still those who place principle over ideology and demagoguery, who realize their larger obligation is to the public good, not their political masters.
This was made evident earlier this week in the tale of Doug Ford's chief of staff, Dean French, a name you may have heard recently as the one who arranged for the firing from OPG of Alykhan Velshi, whose 'crime' appears to be his status as the former chief of staff to Patrick Brown.
French's latest foray into crossing lines has become public knowledge because of some brave insiders who reported his transgression to The Toronto Star.
Premier Doug Ford’s chief of staff ordered senior political aides to direct police to raid outlaw cannabis stores the day marijuana became legal and to show “people in handcuffs,” the Star has learned.Resistance, in any form it takes when dealing with overweening governments, is to be encouraged. The next ray of hope is reflected in Progressive Conservative MPP Amanda Simard, who has found the courage to criticize her own administration:
The edict from Dean French — an unelected political aide — in two conference calls the morning of Oct. 17 met stiff resistance from staff in the community safety ministry and the attorney general’s office, said four Progressive Conservative sources familiar with the situation.
“We’re not a police state. We don’t have the right or the ability to direct police to do anything,” said one insider who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal matters.
Last week, the Ford government announced it was breaking its election promise to build a French-language university, and axed the office of the French-language services commissioner. The government said the office’s responsibilities would be absorbed by the provincial ombudsman.Simard is apparently one of the few truly bilingual members of the Ford government, and is also the parliamentary assistant to Ford lapdog and Francophone Affairs Minister Caroline Mulroney.
In a rare move, Progressive Conservative MPP Amanda Simard released a statement on her Facebook page saying she was disappointed by the cuts.
“You have an ally in me, and I will never let you down,” Simard said in a translated version of the post. She said the cuts “disappoint me greatly, and I share this disappointment and frustration today, having initially worked internally as much as possible to reverse these decisions.”
Why is this an example of the integrity and courage we all pine for in our politicians? Make no mistake about it: she will pay a heavy price for her independent thinking. People like Ford, often described as a bully during his one term on Toronto city council, expect unquestioning fealty from all their adherents. It is the way of the authoritarian, and examples must be set when people step out of line.
Expect a demotion for Simard in the near-future. But while she may lose influence, she has achieved something far more important. She has shown that resistance is never futile, that every defiant gesture is a refusal to submit to arbitrary authority. Such is the human spirit, not yet vanquished.
One hopes Simard's example and that of the insiders who refused to defer to Dean French may serve to inspire others in the time to come.
I was also struck by Simard's bravery in speaking out with her concerns with her 'leaders' decision, I just wonder how long it will take before she pays the price for doing so.
ReplyDeleteCant have MPPs thinking for themselves now can we!
Doubtlessly, Rural, Ford will have to move fast if he is to keep the rest of his 'sheeple' in line.
Delete.. the lesson embedded in this example is perhaps, the dog and its tail. we have an Ontario Government, its related majority political party and opposition members. Of course we expect and have seen proof they are essentially, one and the same.. ie the actual Government is in fact the majority Party & opposition and the majority Party & opposition is in fact the actual Government. Thus, for various and sundry reasons, Ontarions elected a majority political party plus some fringe MPP's
ReplyDeleteSo how is that working out.. currently ?
If the electorate have employed a majority group of candidates, from one particular political party to ensure overall Government is perfectly responsive to their needs, dreams and wishes.. (public service) then how is that going right now ? Perhaps Doug Ford or others could report to us, their employers on how their job performance is going. After all, we are paying their salaries and their pensions.
If we hired them to deliver the mail, would we not expect them to accomplish just that.. ? We would not expect them to open, close or operate casinos on the side, erect statues of themselves or design automobiles.. No, it would be 'show us the mail' .. non ?
So I wonder if we are the dog and Doug Ford et al are the tail.. who is wagging whom here ? Who are these unelected outliers & aides we are hearing about ? Oh ! Are they members of a political party ? And ? Well, if they are useful.. how do we communicate with them or ensure they report to us via appropriate, transparent channels.. after all, we cannot have such people running their own agenda, at our expense, now can we ?
After all.. the tail does not wag the dog.. and Doug is purportedly the leader of the tail.. and that's all. He is not the dog, much less the alpha dog.. more a figurehead. He is our employee, our public servant.. and if mainstream media is confused about this.. they need to be educated on how democracy works.. or is blindsided
One can only ope there are sufficient numbers out there that care enough about the principles of democracy to learn more and demand better, Sal. The evidence for that thus far is less than compelling, something I suspect the Ford Company is counting on.
Delete