Friday, November 3, 2023

UPDATED: Powerful Political Leadership

As the war between Israel and Gaza rages on, it is almost too painful to watch the devastation that the former is inflicting on the latter. I have always been steadfast in my view that criticism of Israel, which is clearly warranted in its ongoing retaliation for the horrible Hamas attack, is not a manifestation of anti-Semitism, but rather the valid criticism of a nation-state, something we do regularly when other countries overstep their bounds.

Sadly, however, politics being what it is, most 'leaders' are loathe to engage in anything more than pro-forma declarations of Israel's right to defend itself, while inserting parenthetic sympathy for the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Political courage and leadership are most often singularly lacking in the discussion.

Nonetheless, most right-thinking people are undoubtedly appalled by the rising number of anti-Semitic outrages being committed these days under the pretext of reaction to Israel's actions in Gaza. People are being attacked, children are afraid to venture out to school, places of worship are being desecrated. None of this can be justified. 

Germany, which knows well the cost of anti-Semitism, offers an especially lucid and heartfelt analysis of the ugliness that is spreading; given its history, what it says matters. German Vice-Chancellor Robert Habeck released the following nine-minute video, which merits careful viewing and careful reflection. It makes a clear distinction between legitimate criticism of the Jewish state and anti-Semitic actions. Even if you don't have the time to watch the entire piece, try to watch some of it, as the concern, compassion, balance and historical context contained therein are well-worth your consideration.



UPDATE: Thanks to Toby for providing this link to a full transcript of Habeck's speech.

9 comments:

  1. I found the video hard to follow because I don't speak German and I found it awkward to follow the subtitles. For others like me National Post has a transcript. https://nationalpost.com/opinion/german-vice-chancellor-supporting-hamas-will-be-met-with-criminal-charges-or-deportation

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks very much for the link, Toby. I shall add it to the post.

      Delete
  2. .. watching this one carefully Lorne.. watching myself carefully too
    .. premonitions incoming - like rapid but distant gunfire.. so far

    can this get far worse.. ? Oh yes.. yes, I really think so..
    Am I being cryptic ? & Why.. Yes yes yes..
    & meanwhile the stench of Yellow Media is pouring ..
    from every pore of Poilievre.. as I try to even conceive
    of worse to come from such an ethical walking talking
    septic tank.. 🦎

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It truly is a powderkeg, Sal. As for people like Poilievre, well, those who would make political hay from tragic situations should be, and are, beneath our contempt.

      Delete
  3. Other than the fact that he does not seem to know much history, even German history, it was an interesting speech.

    He also seems to confuse anti-antisemitism with anti-Israeli sentiment.

    It''s difficult to tell but is he confusing support for the Palistinian people with support for Hamas?

    From what I have heard or read both anti-semitic and anti-Islamic incidents and attacks are on the rise in Canada and I think in Germany. I might have been more impressed with the speech if he had showed a bit more concern for German citizens of Muslim background.

    ReplyDelete
  4. While I realize he doesn't give equal time to anti-Muslim sentiment, Anon, I think he is trying to outline both the spread of anti-Semitism and its conflation with the state of Israel. The latter seems to be an excuse for the former in many instances.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Could be. I still was not greatly impressed. His speech would seem likely to antagonize Muslim voters. If nothing else it strikes me as a stupid political move when you are in a shaky government.

    Sahra Wagenknecht's new left-wing party may be picking up a few new voters.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Replies
    1. I did see that, Anon. One hopes that diligence will be rewarded with another criminal investigation.

      Delete