Yes, Mr. Trump
Re “Ottawa says talks with U.S. back on after pulling digital services tax” (June 30): By rescinding the digital services tax within a weekend of Donald Trump’s withdrawal from tariff negotiations, Mark Carney has shown that he is no longer negotiating with Mr. Trump to protect Canadians. He is, in fact, continuing to bow down to threats from a bully who belies all reason when it comes to decision-making. Canada may vehemently refuse to become the 51st state, but it seems to have no problem capitulating to Mr. Trump’s demands without much of a fight.
From committing to a 5-per-cent increase in defence spending, at the expense of more pressing domestic priorities, to bulldozing a bill through Parliament that steps all over Indigenous rights and territories and now immediately backing out of a digital services tax more than a year in the making, this government is showing no signs of standing up to fight for Canada and Canadians.
Themrise Khan Ottawa
So Trump has a tantrum and we blink. Is this elbows up? Is this negotiation? Many other sovereign nations have implemented a digital services tax. But I guess the eventual 51st state should not. What’s next, supply management? It is protected by an Act of Parliament? But that law can also be rescinded when Mr. Trump pulls out again in a couple of days.
Sinclair Robinson Ottawa
Knuckling under to Mr. Trump’s blackmail on the digital services tax is a shameful betrayal. Not only is it a weak and pathetic response, it is also stupid. Giving in to blackmail only invites him to do it again and again and again – and he will.
Trevor Hancock Victoria
I used to tell my students that we are as Canadian as the U.S. lets us be. Sadly proven true yet again.
Kevin Byrne Sarnia, Ont.
So we implement a digital services tax, a questionable move on its own, and then we withdraw it because Mr. Trump has a public tantrum. Now we look foolish and weak. Mr. Trump’s bombast, disinformation and bullying represent one end of the negotiation tactic field. The Prime Minister has just identified the other end of that playing field.
Mark Knudsen Mississauga
One of the first rules of negotiation is to give to the other side only if you get something in return. Otherwise, it will encourage them to push for further concessions. Eliminating the digital services tax on U.S. tech giants is a step backward for Canada. We are chipping away at Canadian sovereignty by allowing the president of another country to set our tax policy.
Neil Tudiver Ottawa
And this one from The Star:
Carney cancelling the digital services tax a weak move
I am horrified to see that Prime Minister Mark Carney has given in to Trump and cancelled the digital services tax.
What makes Carney think Trump will now treat Canada fairly? Is he afraid of the big online companies, the oligarchs?
It’s past time to stand up to Trump and his gang, and make Canada self-sufficient.
Kate Chung, Toronto
No one more than me would like to be proven wrong in condemning Carney for this move. I just don't see that happening, however.